Skip to content

Try

post thumbnail

Lawyers oppose ICC restriction that could exclude victims from trial

In a Nov. 18 filing, the common legal representatives for victims asked Trial Chamber III to clarify that its Oct. 9 ruling does not narrow the participation framework for victims already admitted to the proceedings or those who may apply in the future. 

By Janna Millenas

Nov 19, 2026

3-minute read

Share This Article

:

Lawyers representing victims in the case against former president Rodrigo Duterte before the International Criminal Court have objected to a proposed review that could revoke the status of victims already admitted as participants in the trial.

The objection responds to a Registry proposal to reassess 13 applications it considers outside the scope of the case. This proposal follows Trial Chamber III’s Oct. 9 ruling removing Incident 57 because it fell beyond the time frame covered by the charges against Duterte.

In a Nov. 18 filing, the common legal representatives for victims asked Trial Chamber III to clarify that the ruling does not narrow the participation framework for victims already admitted to the proceedings or those who may apply in the future. 

The CLRV warned that the proposed reassessment could exclude families of victims killed four days after the end of September 2018, even though the killings fell within the “broader presidential period” as confirmed by the Pre-Trial Chamber I.

The Registry also questioned whether the phrase “around July 2016” under Counts 2 and 3 covers crimes committed in June 2016. The victims’ lawyers cautioned that a restrictive interpretation could disqualify applicants whose relatives were killed on June 30, 2016, the date Pre-Trial Chamber I identified as the start of Duterte’s presidential period.

“The resulting prejudice is concrete: victims would lose their previously recognized procedural status through the application of reasoning adopted in a dispute concerning an additional prosecution incident,” the CLRV said.

The lawyers then urged Trial Chamber III to reject the Registry’s proposal and direct it to assess applications under the participation framework established by Pre-Trial Chamber I. Alternatively, they asked the chamber to reconsider the temporal interpretation behind the proposed reassessment.

“Victims previously admitted to participate should therefore retain their status, while future applicants whose circumstances fall within the same framework should be assessed on the same basis and admitted,” the filing said.

Indirect Victims

The CLRV also argued that neighbors and other individuals who witnessed the crimes may qualify as indirect victims, regardless of their relationship to those directly affected.

 Witnessing the violence, the lawyers said, could cause fear that they or their family members might become targets themselves.

Children born after the crimes should likewise qualify as indirect victims if they suffered psychological, social and economic harm from the loss of family members, particularly those who served as household breadwinners,  the victims’ lawyers said.

Lawyers back admission of ex-DDS member’s evidence

In a separate filing, the CLRV supported the prosecution’s request to admit the statements and related materials of P-0002, an alleged former Davao Death Squad member who is now unavailable to testify at trial.

The prosecution interviewed P-0002 from May 10 to 16, 2022, in the presence of Duterte’s lawyer and another counsel appointed to represent him.

The victims’ lawyers argued that Articles 18(6) and 69(4) of the Rome Statute provide sufficient legal grounds to admit P-0002’s evidence. These provisions address the preservation of evidence in certain circumstances involving deferred investigations and the admission of such evidence in court.

The CLRV described P-0002’s statements  as directly relevant and highly probative of the crimes allegedly committed by Duterte and the harm suffered by victims.

“Its admission would be consistent with, and conducive to, the realization of the victims’ right to the truth, as well as to the conduct of a fair and expeditious trial,” the filing said.

Trial Chamber III has yet to rule on the prosecution’s request, with Duterte’s trial  scheduled to open on Nov. 30. 

Get VERAfied

Receive fresh perspectives and explainers in your inbox every Tuesday and Friday.